Skip to main content

Full text of "NASA Technical Reports Server (NTRS) 20060047571: Secondary Electron Emission and the Exploration of Space"

See other formats


Source of Acquisition 
NASA Marshall Space Flight Center 



I & Zj ' * 

•W '.-' - •; 

‘% V ' : * % 

4A ct s. **v- 






Secondary electrons are important to the spacecraft charging process 
and analysis of space system operation in plasma environments 


u 

.© 



<N 



- Lunar surface charging environments 

- Charged dust 
Summary 

J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


The Charging Current Balance Process 


CO 


o 

o 

<N 


£ 

o 

£ 


s 


T3 

G 

cd 


(D 

fc 

cd 

a 



J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


Spacecraft Charging Impacts Space Systems 







N© 

0 s 

© 

© 

a 5 

^ £ 

S§ £ 

® © 5 

N Z 

w »> 
a 

a « 


c ^ 

HH ^ 

+- s 
g I 
i £ 

If 

•e S 
£ © 
H +- 

rvi w 

© c/5 
© 
c3 

a 

(Z5 


*5 

o 

c 

OX) 

C3 

5 

>* 

73 

a 

o 

a 

< 


r- ^ tt ^r 


TT On <-n 
<S rH ^ 


00 IT) 
fS 


^ ON Os id vq 
^ IT) ^ » H 


f f 
2 | 
u g 


•N 

3 


C3 

fi 

Sm 

© 


© 

© 


"§ C/5 

a r r 

*C g 

© cu 

WD C/5 


Km 

nh Z 

a Q 

C/5 C/5 

Ed Ed 


© 

fi 

U> 

o 


rf Q 
u 
o 


p 
Ed 
Ed c/5 


n n n © 
• • • • 

m © O 00 


© tH _| rf 
<N 


© 

</> 

© 


S3 

© 

.2 

,p 3 

ct 

Pi 


Q 

o 


OX) 

9 

C 

g « 

a ^ 

^ j- 
* © 

© pC 

cj 

c*> 

© 

E 


E 

o 


s- 

© 

J= 


—* ^ w ^ 

S ^ < o 


N© 

0 s 


ON 

ON 

n 


as 

© 

H 



Kawakita et al., 2005 J Minow [256] 544-2850 Kawakita et al., 2005 

CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 






Spacecraft Charging Impacts Space Systems 


CM 


^ £ 
“ © 
a a 


95 

G 

CJ 
© 
C J 
fl 

a 

C/5 


cm 

« «> 

a i 


Cl 

s 

s 

o 

« 

a 

o 

C 

fl 

-fl 

Oh 


fl ,3 

2 1 

© r. 

■S « 

rf « 
”3 S& 

*C OD 
^ S3 

§ c 

2 a 

S ° 

K O 
QJ _ 
3D O 
95 

s a 

OS o 

xj cj 


fl 

a 

Ln 

QJ 


a 

© 

u 

u 


3D 

C 

*3 

s- 

93 

ns 

© 

c 

*3 

4H 

CM 

a 

& 


ts 

95 

© 

CM 


© 

+H 

CM 

CM 

© 

£ 

o 

A 


* a 
© $ 

£f « 

A M M - 
pC 2 © w> 
© g -S 3D 

.2 a -g # c 

Q Q S H 


CM 

© 

U 

95 

Sm 

© 



uo 


IT) 

o 

o 

<N 


95 

© 

fl 

a 

A 

£ 

fl 

* 



s© 

0 s 

© 

© 

2 ^ 

Qa a> 

CZ3 ^ ,fi 

sis 

® O ;® 

£ n Z 


oj _• 
a OS 

G HH 
G ^ 
hH 

*- 2 
c 2 
© 2 

H 3 

g “ 
2 2 
£ S 
2 © 

W M 

CM 

© (Z3 
95 

a 

< a 


in 

*3 

o 

G 

3D 

95 

5 

*3 

3 

o 

G 


^ ^ Tf 


^ ^ Os 

n HH gs 


30 if) 
n 


^ 0's ^ */) so 
ITi N X h 


m m m ® 
• • • • 

fO O O 30 


i-H Tf 

n 


“ 3D 

.S e 


3D 


3D 


*C h 

u g 

'a © 
fl 2 
g <2 
© t* 

3 

fi S3 
NH C/5 

I I 

Q Q 

C/5 C/5 

w w 


xs 

© 

.a 

o 


rv 

◄! 

C/3 

r\ 

M 

eu 


CM 

o 


3D C fl 

2 ^ Q 

c 
o 


fl 

CJ 

fl 

& 


Q & 
^ W 
W c/5 


04 

U w 

O c 

w .2 

*^3 

a 

04 


Q 

O 


3D 

fl 

fl 

flj 

§JD .2 

>> u 

O pfl 

CJ Op 

CM 

o 

s 


su 

o 


S § 

LJ W 

S ◄! < O 


V 

S 

QJ 

V 

C/5 

o 

A 

a 
c n 

v 

O 

3 

a 

S 

OD 

3 

# 5i) 

u 

3 

X 

U 


3 

u 

CJ 

a> 

c-> 

3 

a 

C/5 


Vl 

2 » 

2 ■§ 
Cl 


a 

s 

o 

o 

a 

o 

'M 

c 

3 

,3 

C>H 


Q-> 

O 

3 

a 

c/5 

s 

o 

'M 

o 

3 p. 

a q 

a 


% 


s * 

oS o> 

^ £ 
" © 

S a 

• pap C\ 

a 

2 s 

-M W 
U !_ 

2 «3 

® o 
w « 

1 a 

JLZ. 


OX) 

# G 

*3 

Sm 

3 

T3 

CJ 

# G 

*s 

3 

O 

"D 

3 

0> 



OX) 

s 

*5jd 

u 

3 

6 

o 

0> 

3 

Q 

T3 

3 

S 

s 

5m 

QJ 

H 

<*> 

s 

# o 

*33 


</3 

o 


0 J 
c/> 

3 

3 

U 


Q ft Q 

C/5 C/5 C/5 

w w w 


o> QJ 

o o 
.3 ,3 

t: o 

s C/5 


JM 

3 


o> o 

o o 

,3 C^. C^« 3 

*S O Q *2 Q 

s ^ c« S m 


(Zi7iW(/]WW7iW 


a> 

3 

Q 


m 

t ^ 

<N 

00 

00 

00 

ON 

ON 

tH 

Tf 

ON 

r- 

ON 

on 

fH 

ON 

fH 

On 

ON 

'pH 

ON 

3 


c 

Sn 

3 

3 

3 

3 

o 

z 

3 

§ 

3 

3 


s 

VI 


fH 

© 

o 

3 

U 

(S 

Tf 

<N 

i* 

u 

W 

U 

3 

H 

ox 

pc 

PA 



3 

*< 

• mm 

mti 

Vl 

C/5 

A \ 


C 






GEO Surface Charging 


CO 

I 

in 

< 


cc in 

SS 

O , 
yj CO 



O 

H 

U 

o 


o 

co 



SNOaioaia snoi 


O ^ CO ooooco ** 

OO OOr-^OO O 

Or— r“ ^ r- *— r— 

§ IA«) ADH 3 N 3 


CM 

CM 


m 

oo 

Os 


G 

O 

co 


00 

CN 

> 

< 

G 


CM 



Anomalies typically occur in midnight to dawn sector where hot plasma is 
injected during geomagnetic substorms 


GEO Surface Charging 


00 




OVE» J ZB Bo| 


r- j _ » 

H tZ TT 

-so t-e e l -t 




■rA^>3 &C=| C 

M L 

ooyvwts c 

-t-id-o — ^ et-L -b-: 


Eclipse charging events typically reach kilovolt potentials 




Os 


QJ 

OX 

c$ 

s 

C 3 



O 



Cl 

u 

u 



u 

cs 


© 




c 

o 

1/3 

o 

S-l 

cd 

5-h 

<L> 

bx) 

bX) 


c 

T3 cd 
<P dn 


cd 


£ 

i 

c3 



o 

o 

<N 


Ch 

o 


1/3 

2 

bD 

5-H 

<u 



J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 





Secondary Electron Yields 


o 




(SI Q 13 IA N 0 ISSIW 3 ABVQN 003 S 


O 

w 


OX) 

a 

•pN 

OD 

U 

CO 


o 

W 

o 


> 

<L> 

co 


* 

H 


OX) 

s 

•PM 

OX) 

u 

co 


CO 

3m 

O 

3m 

3 


> 

<D 

O 


l 

H 


> 

<D 

O 

o 


0 

1 

H 


> 


0 

i 

1 

> 


> 

o 

o 

o 

r- 

O 


O 

0 

1 

> 


> 

o 

o 


o 

0 

1 

> 


J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


Secondary Yields are Material Dependent 


I 



o 




J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 



Time Dependent SEY 




pPlJLUOjMig Aiscodmb 


m 

<D 

• i-H 
$-H 

o 

m 

o 

13 

# <D 

X) 

cd* 

c 


o 

*£3 

• i-H 
+-> 

o 

cd 

3 

• i-H 

cd 


$-H 


r^5 

o 

bX) 

CD 

2 

Vh 

• i-H 

O 

Q 

• 

*-h 


cd 

G 

73 

cd 

C 

ts 

O 

o 

o 

CD 

& 

C/D 

a 

• i—i 

S 

• i-H 

C/D 


<D 

Id 

bX> 

• i-H 
+- > 

C 

a 

cd 

<D 

o 

+-> 

O 

73 

Ph 

• i-H 

C/D 

rv 73 

cd 

13 

• i-H 

• 




ro 

© 

© 

<N 

rv 

fS 

© 

© 

£ 

H 

i 

U 


1/1 

rv 

oo 

<N 


u 



(N 


J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


CO 


© 

© 

0) 

fl 

© 

a 

© 

Q 

© 

© 

Q 

W 



s 


8 


0>, 

>» 

e> 

© 

c 

LU 

E 

CO 

Q> 

CD 

2T 

CO 

E 

*c 

CL 


-e 

2 

a 

& 

<-l-H 




> 

g 

© 

c 

LU 

E 

CD 

© 

CD 

CO 

E 

•C 

CL 


piaiA uojpaig AjBpuooes 



CM *- O 

PI9!A uojpei 3 Ajepuooas 


(N 

a 

o 

<D 

oo 

© 

H 

X 

00 

• 

r-H 

*H 

<D 

< 

'Tj 


(N 

a 

0 

1 

<D 

oo 

© 

"x 

oo 


u 

<D 

< 


05 

<D 

3 

05 

0 
Oh 
X 
<L> 

1 

<D 

a 

§ 

o 

13 

*-t 

<L> 

a3 

-a 

c 

Cd 

<D 

S-H 

£ 

<L> 

O 


CM 

a 

0 

1 

© 

i— H 

X 

<N 


* 

i-i 

3 

O 

43 


S-i 

£ 


£ 

'S 

a 

<D 

+-> 

C /5 

• i-H 

C /5 

a 

o 

o 

bD 

a 

• rH 

ff 

43 

O 

a3 

od 

<L> 

feb 

05 


T3 

1) 

l-H 

Oh 

<L> 

05 

O 

T3 


£ 

13 




13 

a 

a> 

• r-l 
>> 

C/5 

o- 


< 

I 

O 

f 

-t— > 

3 

C/5 

> 

0) 

<L> 

i-i 

<D 

s 

a 

<D 

Lh 

>* 

E> 

CD 

c 

33 

05 

o 

o 

cd 

CD 

o 

o 

<D 

&• 

o 

LU 

E 

CO 

a 

X 

o 

CJ 

s 

CN 

a 

o 

05 

a 

• l-H 

3 

Vh 

o 

a> 

GO 

CO 

F 

<D 

<L> 

Vh 

H 

<M-H 

O 


<D 

05 

cd 

<D 

1 
▼— H 

— 

•c 

n 

£ 



*h 

O 

m 


<L> 

pq 


<D 

Q 


PQ 

00 

• 

Q 

W 


cd 


Yield depends on angle: 

• SEY values greater at larger incidence angle, predicts reduction in charging 


>H 

w 

oo 

* 

<D 

3 

0) 

a 

<L> 

Q 

c /3 

O 

Q 



o — 
o 13 
<l> ^ 

<D 

T 3 t 3 

"5 S 

P 
<u 


PiaiA Aiepyooas >jead 



e 

■r° O 

° § 
<N 


0) 


(N 


3 


U (N 
c 00 

a ' 

%. m 

U MH 

jg D 

S Ph 

> o 
* < 

8 j 

9 ™ 

GO 

C 

2 

-d 

§ 

>% 

-e 

2 

a 

o 

<& 


E 

o 

40 

0 

1 
a 


ts 

Qj 

ID 

> 

OJ 

o 

Q 


N 

o 


S 

0 

1 

<L> 

oo 

i-H 

o 

X! 

<D 

CO 

0 
dd 

1 

<D 

> 

<D 

O 

O 


S 

o 

"T 

<D 

VO 

r— H 

o 

<D 

C/3 

0 

dd 

1 

(D 

> 

<D 

O 

O 


a 

o 

• I— I 

C/3 


X 

<D 

<D 

Dh 

a 

o 

o 

P 4 

W 

s 


C/3 

o 

•1-H 

C/3 


X 

<L> 

>> 

O 

Id 


*Td 

<D 

ed 

O 

O 

Z 

H 

O 

#\ 

+ 


<L> 

<L> 

C/3 


T 3 

<D 

od 

O 

0 

1 

z, 


cd 


p|ai/» Ajepuooas >iead 


Demonstrates dose dependent changes in peak secondary electron yield 




W 

co 

a 

a 

a 

Q 

a 

H 



73 

<u 

W .2 

P4 73 

H 2 

&H .S 

3* ^ 

d <L> 
co ^~r 

g g 

3 § 

d c/3 
■ — 

<D 
U 



s 

3 


03 .« 

"S « 

<D -+-> 
N cO 
° 

J2 O 


O 

m 

J-l 

«s 

c« 

d 

O 

J-l 

't-* 

o 

« 

> 

<D 

m 


4h 

T3 2 

§ § 

g -d 

<D £ 
J-H O 

3 & 

I D ^ 
d 73 
73 c 


N® 

o x 


s >> 

03 


GO 

<L> 

GO 

a 

<D 

o 

C 


CO 

5 3 

'5 J§ 


o 

m 

<L> 

>> S 

w 

73 

<2 co 

’"” - 1 rH 


0) 

(U .5 

73 

o 

73 d 

<L> 

d 

• i— i g 

o 

73 

x S 

d 

a> 

O c 

73 

j-i 

4-i O 

<D 

j 

to 

O O 



& 

<L> 

J-i 

43 
-<— * 

W) 

d 

'5b 

g 

43 

O 


X 

O 


° H 
oo -4 

2 * 
5 I 

cn > 

vo £ 
m ^ 
<n vo 
o 
^ o 

£ (N 
O M 
d 2 


< 

V 


(Davies and Dennison, 2000) 


Threshold Temperature for Charging Onset 


SNOH13313 


SNOI 



A9H3N3 




> 

O 

ac 


o 

.r * 


8 


*1 

*1 


o 

ui 


> p 

< - 

z 

£ 

a. 





^ U 


(9* 013IA NOISSIW3 AHV0N003S 



Examples of T crit Onset 



U 

H 

U 

cz) 

5 

oo 


ro 

© 

© 

C4 

«N 


O 

<D 

C/5 

G 

O 

Vh 

£ 

C/D 

<L> 


cd 

O 


o 

a3 
d 

_ bD 

& *s 

S W) 

(73 
O 


c3 

X 

w 


<D 

5-h 

3 

a 

i-H 

<D 

I 

(D 


J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


Te Threshold 


OC 



8 8 8 8 

a a a a 

y - in n 

I I I I 



C3 



J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


Trapped Photoelectrons and Sunlight Charging 


o 


sc 

o 


Os 


< 

X 

a: 

Lii 

> 

O 

—i 

< 

F 

z 


O 

CL 


g 

</> 

i— 
X ZJ 
UJ Z 

GC 3 
CK CO 

< L±] 

CO X 
Q H 

z z 

< o 


- ^ 


B 

1 

QC 

<p 


as 

00 


S 

i 


-s g 
8 P ‘ e 


D 

43 

CO 


CO 

o 

Qh <d 

g o 

5 ,cx * 

3 S (S 


,-5 

E 




10 

6 




(A>l -) 1VllN310d IdVaoaDVdS 


£ 


o 

m 

oo 

(N 

I 

5 


X 

H 


in 

(N 



O 

W 

O 


bX) 

3 

• H 

bX) 

c3 

33 

o 


§ 

o 

+-> 

33 

bX) 

» i»H 

*3 

3 

c/3 


<D 

> 

• 1-H 
+-> 
cd 
bX) 

3 


C/3 

8 g> 

cd 


3 ^ 

bX) O 

3 o 

£3 *1— i CZ) 

(/) Q d 




SNOdioaia 


(AM) A9H3N3 


ELECTRON TEMPERATURE (keV) 



o 

<N 



( Z> 


© 

© 




§ a 

a) « 
P & 

CO g 

a> P 
W) S 

C O 
00 P 

a <l> 
43 


co 

5-1 

<D 


o <1> cd 

& fc*-° 


2 od a 
P TD 
co s 

O 
o 
a> 


o 

o 

PQ 


a 

<D 


co Qh 


Flux #/ (cm^sec-eV ) 




(ASM) A0U3N3 


CO <N *■ © 

(IVI) 1H1N3KM 


© 

o 

<N 



a> 



u 

4 ) 

£ 

k 

D 


o 

© 


w 


o 

© 

© 

© 


J.Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 





D 

O 

c 

cd j 

-G 

4-* 

c 

D 

fa 

G 

o 

d 

jG 

D 

4-> 

cd 

G 


o 


T3 


C /3 

« * 


G 


<D 


fa 


G 


o 

D 

G 

> 
• fH 

O 

4— > 

• r-H 

faJ 

o 

CO 

o 

^D 

a 


D 

O 


4-» 

>— i 

o 

cd 


Gb 

a 

D 


A 


• 4h 

K*n G 

of) 5_ 

G o 

•1—1 fli 

go o 

=3 S > 

■s - ^ 

■P’S 

cd 


G 

• l-H 

£ 

Jh 

'o 

C/3 


C/3 

C /3 

D 

O 

O 

J-h 

Gh 


2 

C /3 

g 

o 


C /3 

g 

CD 

fa 

G 

o 

b 

cd 

G 

O 

o 

<u 

C /3 

C /3 

cd 


a/ 

£ 

C /3 

cd 

C /3 


C 

<d 

^ fc 

?p 3 


<D 

c 

<D 

£ 

o 


C /3 

G 

O 

J-l 


G 

CD 

JG 

‘o 

G 

• l-H 

a-> 


G 

S 

O 

ffl U 


o 

CL) 


<D 


Cd 

X 

<D 

<N 

*• 

O 

C /3 

cd 

£ 


cd 

4-> 

o 

<D 

a 


<§ 

cd 

X 

W 


I I I 


<N 


J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


Near Earth Plasma Regimes 


<N 

CM 



03 

<L> 

-C 


<L> 

G 

Si) 

E 


a 

<D 

JG 


O 

c 

Si) 

03 


£ 



^ U 




fl 




LO 



m 

<N 


u 

H 

U 

CZ3 

Xj 

as 


a 

+* 

a 

a 

no 

o 

s 

s 

C/5 



GO 

+-> 

a 

<L> 

§ <D 

3 -g 

a 
o 
u 
+-> 

o 

JD 

13 

o 


o 

G3 

Ph 


<D 

Cd 

G 

• i-H 

a 

o 

'O 

G 

cd 

O 


CO 

■+■■* 

G 

a> 


- g 
4G cd 
cd Gh 
V-i co 

o 
a> 
o 
cd 


c« 


C/3 

C3 


S A 


bo 

• i-H 

CO 

a 

M- 

GO 

G 

• i-H 

bJQ 

G 

"O 

G 

O 

• f-H 

cd 

ed 

£ 

• i-H 
> 

O 

CD 

rG 

o 

o 

G 

<D 

O 


Cu 


& £ 

a> « 


J.Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 



'O 

c 

• i-H 
£ 



o 

c 

• i-H 

(73 

<D 

GO 




O 

O 

<N 


c3 
'(— > 
<D 

<73 

N 

00 



i/i 

c 

o 

La 

-w 

u 

"3 

o 

O 

X 

cu 


• • 




Cluster Example 


IT) 

<N 



J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


Photoelectron Charging 



4-H 

o 

G 

O 

G 

& 

03 

G 

O 

S 

<D 

"O 

<N 

§ 


u 

c/3 

u 

<D 

OD 

G 

u 


o 


4* 

U 

« 

44 

u 

O 

H 

s 

o 

> 


is cd 

y < r-^H 

cd ^ 

•rj t/3 

G *=J 
« O 
+-» 

o > 

Gh S 
<G & 


o 

is 

G 

O 

o 

Id 

• 

+- > 
G 

<D 

-t— > 

O 

Gh 

3G 

cd 

S-H 

o 

<D 

O 

cd 

Gh 

03 


cd 

J-H 

o 

<D 

O 

cd 


G 

<L> 

£ 

O 


02 


4h 
<D ° 

> | 

+-> c 

•a « 

o g 

Gh <5 
4^ g 


O 

G 

O 

+-> 

o 

•§ 

C-> 


fc 

Q 

E 

Si 

& 

V) 


e 

0 
* 

s 

1 

ti 

§ 

o 

o 

0. 

-o 

< 



8 R 


irt vrt o 

— 55 ^ 

*6 *1 ** 


a $ 2 

Si * <? 


in 

i: ad p 


a di O 
<n 

2 ^ 


C88 

*1 "T O 


<N 


5> 


o * 

— CM 

» ^ d 


[/J lj*jaao»0£ 


8 8 55 

<& 4 d 


SJS 


2 £ 


"O 

<D 


o 

<D 

53 


cd 

G 


CZ> 

cd 

<D 

a 

£ 

o 

Id 


a 

« o 

<D T3 

« <g 

^ a 

2 o> 

o £ 
J> Gh 

t> 03 


G G 

<D cd 

I S' 

O « 

Vh , ~ 

-5 

& o 


cd 

+-> 

o 

4-> 

<L> 

G 


bi) © ^ 
G O O 


J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 





a a a o o 

2 s ° ° s 


<S}|OA) leiiuaiOd 


(®a) 3S9 AX 


r- 

CN 


I 


J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


Auroral Charging 



J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


Auroral Charging 


ON 

<N 



- ll l f lll fl ll jl ll|l [III I |II N * ~l ~| II l I | l I 

OO (M H O <J)vr CO CM OO 


3 f D 01 


3 DAV 


CM 

£N 0^13313 


r“jTTi i |in r | ii 

^ 00 CM 

SNOI 


on 


CL 

< 


<7i 

o 

(^la^co^ 
^LA TT 

r-i I r\l I H 

o 


o 

Pi A<7irA^r 
o^cci o oo ^ 

H I (M I fM 
O 


r\j 

9 lA CO pvj O') 
2?<ri la\o T 

H I (M I f\l 
O 


^r 

’SW 

<rH I 


T 

ko OA 

I f\J 


SN0^1D313 


(A3) AD*3N3 D01 


(£> 

P.^.co^r 

TT^>2^>rM 


CO 

9f^ m corA 

fV \A 2 LA rA 
rl I ^ I O 


- 

ro m£ la 
H I ^ I O 


hhZhh 

^35s 


J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


Auroral Charging 




1711 1 ft 1 f i i 1 

CO CM «— 1 O CO CM 



3fD01 3 DAV 

OO 

-h £N 0^13313 
u_ 


SN 0^13313 SNOI 

(A3) AD^3N3 301 


CL 

< 


o 

9i^ k rsj 
rsi rsi 9 

r—i 1 r\j 1 rsi 
O 


O 

P.TtTtKO'T 
2^r\i^r ™ 

TKCO^rH 
H 1 rsj 1 (M 

o 


o 

9<£>U>r\JO 

^l^<71kO<H 
H I (M I OJ 

o 


o 

9cri ro.k£> <71 

u> r< rl 

~co ^ ko r\i 
r-i 1 rvx 1 rsi 

o 


o 

9orsjkOO 
<71 CO 9 
TcorA^r^j 
H 1 rA 1 N 

o 


o 

9coLArsi^r 

!£<ri <7-1 <ri ^ 
TTr^ LA k£> m 

H 1 (Y\ I f\| 

o 


o 

9r- 


rsi 




<71 

w 

k£>fA 
1 rsj 


hhZhh 


O 

cn 


J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARJ 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


Lunar Dust Charging 


CO 



2 

13 




<D 

cd 


<D 

W) 

c3 

43 

O 

a> 

o 

<D 

J-H 





J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


Lunar Secondary Electron Environments 





^ © 
0 C J 

§ «s 

J 0 

a E 

O 0 
£ fi 

© a 
0 +- 
©< a 
•a fi 
5 0 
a «, 

2 © 

0 ° 
•g 0 
0 0 
p§ 5 

3 zr 

© O 

© l-H 

O 1 

Z ^ 
.2 ©* 
"O © 

0 C/5 

u © 

OX) "2 
0 © 

*35 *S 

3 « 
rs 
rv 

2 * 

a a 
a 2 

S5 5: 

o % 

s ° 

.2 © 


u 

0 

0 


ITi 


w © 
> © 

2 ^ 
a ^ 
£ 0 
^ 4 > 

> a 


0 

0 

2 s o 

s ^ 

S §< 


a 

© 


0 

© 

s =«= 

•0 ^t 
Lx O 
© MX 

A ^ 

X > 

w _g 

Lx 

o 


C/5 
/— \ 

w 

H 

J 

a, 

U 


© 

© 

a 

Q 

0 

© 

m 0 
0 2 
a s 

^ Lx 

« « 

5 ft 

C8 * 

• w 

6 *- 

3 S 

C/3 <U 

</> £ 
^ s 

i/T 2 

~V 

(N C 

m w 

O La 

33 X 
o e 
ft s 
< J 

H 

It 

cm 0 
'M fiL 

0 — 

© "© 

e © 

OX 

g Lx 

b 0 

© a 

x U 

41 -p* 

s 2 

3 O 

+* a 
*s © 

■ a 

5 < 


c m 

a 

© 

© 

a 

C/5 


fN 

r- 

OS 


© 

a 

Lx 

0 

a 

a 

0 

0 

Lx 

© 

0 

© 

C/5 

0 

© 

06 


| § 

C i 

° a 

© S 

a © 

0 © 

a 5- 

a © 

0 fa 


o 

w 


C/5 

© 


0 

> 

© 

OX 

Lx 

0 


fO 

a 


T3 

0 

i 

Lx 

i2 

© 

cz> 


C/5 


© 


© 


0 

CM 

0 

© 


© 

C/5 

• pX 

0 

'C 

0 

© 

0 

0 

CM 

t3 

^0 

© 

0 


0 

0 

^0 

a 

0 

©X 

0 

© 

a 

•XX 

0 

CM 

’XX 

© 

© 


’XX 

© 

© 

0 

0 

OX 

OX 

0 

0 

s 

s 



<s 

r- 

os 


^ £ 


0 

+x 

© 

Lx 

© 

a 

© 

0 

a 

Lx 

© 

0 

© 


© 

© 

,0 

©X 

© 

0 

C/5 

0 


Lx 

5 * 

4) .35 

3 W5 

E s 

4» 

7 ^ 

c m 

-fl s 

w 


01) 

s 

_0> 

a > 
>> 

X) 

a> 

Q 

s- 

3 

s 

3 

nJ 


C/5 

0 

© 

© 

+x 

© 

© 


ro 


V5 

0 

© 


0 

© 

Lx 

0 

© 

OX 

0 

'ox 

© 

0 

a 

© 

© 

a 

•a 

0 

TJ 


§ 8 

a ^ 

s t: 

© 0 

XI ^ 

5/5 a 

0 ° 

0 <*> 

2 Jg 

+x © 

§5 ts 

■s a 

1 * 
X £ 
ft 3 


I I 


x 

H 

€ 

o 

£ 


'o £ 
in ^ 

<N. un 


o 



O O o o o o 

to ’SL to <N 




[UJ>(] apnwiv 




Lunar Dust Charging Models 


(ujri) ( p j) snipej U!Bj6 jsoq 




[uij (*™ Z ) xe^j 



O 

o 

<N 


a 

+-> 

<L> 

C/3 

X 

X 

s 

00 


(D 

T3 

O 

a 


c 

3 

£ 


x 

X) 

CD 

03 

C 


a s 

• f-H 


a 

o 

T3 


CO 


CO 

4-> 

CJ 

<D 

fci 

o 


■2 o 

Cy • rH 


o 

u 

o 

o 


a g 

| fc 

Q U 

I I 


la 

3 is 

C G* 

2 ’S 

o cd 

<D c/3 

« -a « 

§ 

-g^ § | 

Qh co 


CO 

a 

<D 

fc 

o 

a 

o 

S-H 

•4-> 

o 


a 

CD 

fc! 

3 

o 

CD 


Jd x 

<D £ 

a* <D 
'rt +-> 

C ° 

0 ^ 

8 S?-* 
“ e -S 

3 <D O 

fflisa 

1 


CO 

CO 


J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 



SEY Properties of Lunar Dust, Simulants 





> 

<D 

^ >> > 

O o <D d> 

«> 4444 44 

9 't 

o o © © 

CO 

O 


? r i T t 

to co co co 


C/3 

<D 

ts 

c3 

§ 


o 

co 


U 

oo 


i 

C/3 

h-l 


o 

£ 


oo 


jb « 

• S<N 

^ <N 

§ L 

•Th -G 
G .G5 

.£P£ 

C/3 

<D G 

o ^2 

4=* o 

— ! G 


cd 

a 

CZ3 

O 

o 


co 

ON 

cd 

r- 

ON 

i ^ 

ON 

aaaJ 

i— H 

<L> 

r\ 

• 

13 

<D 

C/3 

13 

+-> 

<D 

+-> 

(D 

O 

<a 

crj 

c/) 

• i-H 

• fH 


o 

£ 

o 

ffi 

m 


C/3 

G 
O 

£ 

o 

<D 
<L> 13 

s_i 

cd cd 
co £ 
T3 oo 

13 

•P*®* 

8a 
G*g 
W) 5> 

G ^ 

OO © 
On 75 

2 o 

C/3 
1/3 

<D 
O 

o 

Vh 
Oh 

W) 
G 


cd 

G3 


J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 


u 

© 

QJ 

On 

</> 

o 

u 

Oh 

s* 

cl 

fl 




co 


G 

<L> 


1/3 


o 

C/3 

^ T3 

o § 

G 

O 

t-H 

o ^ 
o > 

G 

O 

£ 

o 

— ^ 

S ° 


>N 

o 

G A 

<D 

tj) 

u 

<D 

y 1 H 

o o 

o 
+- » 


<D 

o ^ 

o 

§4/ 

' O 
+-> 

o 

C/J 

C/3 *t7 

O 

Gh 


O 

O 

>% 

X) 

'O 

<D 

• i-H 

S 

<D 


G 

<d 

s 


C/D 

fl 

• i-H 

Ph ’Tj 

W « 

03 

<D g 

G £ 


(ss^jbap) 9|6 uv 



J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX 



VO 

cn 



3 

O 

C/5 




<2 

a 

o 

• i-H 

o 3 

C 3 





Cd i — i 

*_» <N 
<D On 

a 2 

o ^ 

t /5 r 

+2 —5 
G c 3 

O O 
O m 

T & 

2 00 

H 2 


I 


•3 c 

«> 2 

<D E 

V3 o 

G 

tin O 

rH Vh 

G +-> 
•i—i o 

£? 8 

cd a> 
43 o 
o 

W o 

<c .G 

2 ^ 
o o 
<D rj 
O w 
cd ^ 

&43 
50 00 
00 43 
G G 

W) S 

G Cj_^ 

^ © 

^ 4 *H 

43 O 

U 


oo 

G 

► i"H 

c 3 

6 D 

<L> 


C /5 

Id 

"C 

<D 





X 


in ^ 
oo -r 
(N -S 

I Th 

5 1 
»n > 

vO £ 
m ^ 
<N vo 
o 
^ o 

> (N 


C* 

< 

< 

U 





T3 cd 

s ^ 

O o 

W) 

<D 

.fa go 

a s 

§ 

C/3 


a 

a> 

s 

a 

o 


Cw 

o 

a 

o 

• l-H 

-4-> 

o 

G 


a «j 

« CO 

W) ^ 
G co 

t>0 2 
jh a> 
cc 


43 

O 


C/3 


>> 

_i C/3 

G a) 
O o 

fa cf3 

cd G 
'33 <D ^ 

I §% 
a| s 

<fa o 

cd o 

$-i (D 

O w 

8 ^ 

s ° 

Oh CO X) 

CO fa <D 

( 4 _i ri c/3 
TT <D ^ 

O C ^ 
co g ^2 

•i-H cu 5 

M h 5 

4-h co G 

cd cd fa 
G ^ cd 

< s s 


<D 

O 

cd 

Gh 

CO 

G 

O 




r- 

m 


J. Minow [256] 544-2850 
CAARI 2006, Ft. Worth, TX